Just a Robin Question

gailsimone:

Just curious, there is a lot of love for the various Robins, here.

So my question is, can you put the five Robins in order from least favorite to most beloved?

No judgments, just wondering.

In this order.

1. Stephanie Brown

1. Tim Drake

1. Jason Todd

1. Damian Wayne

1. Dick Grayson.

See what I did there? They’ve all got the same number, because there’s no way I could chose. Ever.

I love Steph simply because of how hard she tries and how she never takes no/give up/you can’t do this for an answer.

I love Tim, because… honestly his thought process is the most like my own. It’s actually really nice seeing a character in fiction who overthinks and overreacts mentally just like me.

I love Jason because… because I can’t not love him. He was a lot of things, but killing him off just left such a bad taste in my mouth. Why do this to such a bright, eager, kid? It just doesn’t seem right.

Oh Damian how I love thee. You with the bad attitude, temper, and general weird habits. You’re adorable and I love little things like Steph dragging him into a moon bounce for some “fun”. I look forward to watching him grow and develop. Admittedly slightly less so now that Stephanie isn’t actively around to make him act his age. Who’s going to do it now that she can’t?


Ah Dick, he of the unfortunate name. If anything I love him just because I get to make Dick jokes. He’s also the first and admittedly I loved his year one story. He goes through so much trying to be Bruce’s partner that my heart just couldn’t not go out to the boy. I do wish he’d get some time with Steph though, I think the two of them could relate a whole lot on that front. But lol wishful thinking much? Since when did DC bother with things that weren’t much more than “Punch random bad guy X in the face”?

So yes. I just cheated and explained why I love all of them. Could I pick a “favorite of my favorites”? No, not really because I’m a wuss and want to be fair to a bunch of fictional characters and picking one of them out of the others wouldn’t be fair.

11 September 2011 at 8:39pm with 159 notes
origin: gailsimone | via: gailsimone

  1. symphonyine reblogged this from crhodey
  2. outbreakblog reblogged this from gailsimone
  3. crhodey reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    So. I started to read every single answer to this...and immediately thought
  4. fanoffandom reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    I can’t actually do that. I...them all so much for different reasons. They’re all distinct...
  5. doktoraiesplace reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    In the interests of the time honoured tradition of ‘wanting to play too’… Although as this
  6. awastrelmescalined reblogged this from madelinelime and added:
    Would you believe me if I said Carrie was the first Robin I ever read? She’s fantastic. I don’t usually count her in...
  7. bethwithfeels reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    I would think that most people’s lists (from most favorite to least) go something like: Dick Grayson, Tim Drake, Damian...
  8. runespoor7 reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    5. Tim, 4. Damian, 3. Dick, 2. Steph, 1. Jason.
  9. closetedboggart reblogged this from dogunderwater and added:
    Damian Wayne Stephanie Brown Jason Todd Dick Grayson Tim Drake
  10. thegoddamnemily reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Oh noes, just realised this was lest favourite...beloved. I did it the other way round!...
  11. major-g reblogged this from madelinelime and added:
    My preference is: Damian Wayne, Jason Todd, Stephanie Brown/Dick Grayson/Carrie Kelley, Tim Drake
  12. mrgammakay reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    All I can say, here and now, is that...no shame in being last on this list. NO SHAME. I...
  13. davidjcutler reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Least to most: Jason Todd, Stephanie Brown, Damian Wayne, Dick Grayson, Tim Drake. Were they spaced out
  14. hugintheraven reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    All Robins except Steph are spoken for. >< … Wait, you said 5. Meaning that you remember she exists. “Spoken for or in...
  15. beardybabble said: Least to Most Loved: 1. Stephanie Brown 2. Tim Drake 3. Jason Todd 4. Dick Grayson 5. Damian Wayne Carrie Kelley and Earth-2 Dick Grayson would fit in between Dick and Jay.
  16. comicette reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    ever. Tim, Damian, Jason, Dick, Stephanie. The three inbetween are almost completely interchangeable when it comes
  17. julianodesousa said: Damian Wayne, Jason Todd, Dick Grayson, Stephanie Brown and Tim Drake
  18. cbrownjc reblogged this from mayak46 and added:
    Jason Todd, Damian Wayne (granted though, I haven’t read a lot with Damian Wayne … )
  19. completehogwash reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Well if there are no strings attached….. Dick, Tim, Stephanie, Damian, Jason But dont get me wrong! I love all of them...
  20. ealperin reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Just curiosity. That’s all. ;)
  21. gailsimone reblogged this from spookytanuki and added:
    was only asking out of curiosity, honestly....Robins are spoken for or in
  22. mayak46 reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Damian Wayne, Jason Todd, Tim Drake, Stephanie Brown, Dick Grayson
  23. fuckingimpala reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Least to Most? Also, I take this as, “while they were Robin.” Stephanie Brown (I like her better as Batgirl. It’s not a...
  24. illbeyourmidnightblaze reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    1. Tim Drake 2. Dick Grayson 3. Damian Wayne 4. Stephine Brown 5. Jason Todd
  25. spookytanuki reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Hmm… Why is Gail Simone asking about Robin? Does this mean something? Okay, least favorite to most beloved Robins: Dick...
  26. meyllendjneres reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Most Beloved? This is based purely on their runs as Robin. 6. Jason Todd 5. Tim Drake 4. Carrie Kelly 3. Damien Wayne 2....
  27. sheroes reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    In this order. 1. Stephanie Brown 1. Tim Drake 1. Jason Todd 1. Damian Wayne 1. Dick Grayson. See what I did there?...
  28. madelinelime reblogged this from awastrelmescalined and added:
    …and Carrie is so unloved, she is always forgotten. :[
  29. youre-a-dalek-harry said: For me at least, 1) Stephanie 2) Damian 3) Dick 4) Tim 5) Jason
  30. never-do-i reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    6. Dick 5. Carrie 4. Timmay 3. Damian 2. Steph 1. JASON TODD
  31. nilamarthiel reblogged this from alexanderperchov and added:
    Jason | Steph Dick | Tim Damian I still have weird feelings about Damian, but this is probably because I went on my DC...
  32. atnervesend reblogged this from mar-void and added:
    I actually quite like Carey but I was only taking main line canon Robins into account.
  33. iconuk01 reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    5 Steph - Felt like...marketing stunt, played out like a marketing stunt. Like the...
  34. mar-void reblogged this from atnervesend and added:
    >five Robins >no one counts Carey Kelly >I hate this life
  35. mambo-sauce said: Tim, Damian, Dick, Jason, Stephanie
  36. c-alluvion reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    I haven’t picked up comics with Robins in them for...good things from Tim
  37. reavien reblogged this from peppers-pray and added:
    Ahahah I’m gonna get shot for this a few times, probably. Steph, Tim, Dick and then Jay and Damian tie for first because...
  38. ajmoser said: Favorite to least favorite: Dick, Damian, Tim, Jason, and whoever else is the 5th one (from DKR?)
  39. peppers-pray reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    That’s a weird arrangement, I wonder how many missed that and put their faves first. Alright, least fave to most...
  40. scarlettmi reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Least Favorite (and I still...the “least” favorite) to Most Beloved: Stephanie Brown...
  41. dogunderwater reblogged this from yabamena and added:
    Edit: Wait, least fave to most fave? Jason Todd Dick Grayson (but mostly as Nightwing) Stephanie Brown Tim Drake Carrie...